Legalism:
1. Excessive adherence to law or formula.
2. Theology - dependence on moral law, rather than on personal religious faith.
I asked in my first post on
Freedom in Christ vs. Legalism ... where do you fit? Do you find yourself more on the Freedom in Christ side of things, or the Legalistic side of things?
I, myself, find that question difficult to answer.
If you were to ask random acquaintances of the Big D family which side we fit on ... I'm sure they would tend to say that we are legalistic ... that we have a lot of "Rules to Live By".
However, if you were to ask close friends of the Big D family ... I would expect that they would say we were closer to the Freedom in Christ side of things. We give a lot of grace, when the rules are not lived up to.
Last January, I wrote a post about
Rules vs. Relationships. It talked about how, in parenting, Rules without Relationships often equals Rebellion. I believe that the same is true with our faith. If all we see in the Bible is the rules, than we are much more likely to rebel against the authority of it. Yet, when we view the Bible as the key to building our relationship with Christ, than we will view the rules entirely differently.
I believe that the "rules" in Scripture are absolutely important, yet the relationship is of primary importance. I so desire to obey the rules, because of my deep love relationship with the author of those rules.
On the "Legalistic" side of things ... I DO believe it is important to "obey the rules". When God's Word tells us to do something, that means He wants us to do it (
or not do it, as the case may be).
God's Word tells us to obey our governing authorities. I believe that this means we are to obey the laws of the land, unless they were to directly contradict God's Word. How does this apply to my daily life?
#1 I'm a stickler for driving the speed limit. Absolute stickler.
#2 I follow the arrows at the gas pump. I really do. (
Now, even though this may not be a legal law, I want to set the example for my children that I "follow the rules".)
#3 I go back to a cashier if they forgot to ring something up. If I went home with an unpaid for item, that would be stealing. I waited patiently in a busy grocery store once, when I realized that the clerk hadn't rung up my $1.25 package of toilet paper. I needed to pay for it.
#4 I am VERY careful to do my taxes honestly and ethically. I am SHOCKED by how many Believers think it's "okay" to cheat the government out of "a little" money.
Now ... some people would call me legalistic, because I am very concerned about following the rules. However, it is NOT about the rules ... it's about my relationship with Christ, that is so very important to me, that I want to do all I can to bring honor and glory to Him.
Sometimes, I actually HATE following the rules. It is NOT always easy to "play by the rules". But, out of OBEDIENCE, I know that I must. Here is the perfect example of the biggest area that I HATE following God's rules. I don't have much of a problem going 65mph, when the Speed Limit tells me to, However, in California, while everyone else is allowed to go 65 or 70 ... vehicles pulling trailers are "required" to drive 55mph. I HATE pulling my trailer the entire length of CA (750+ miles). NO ONE else follows the rules. NO ONE! Other drivers even get mad at me for following the law ... I'm in their way. Sometimes, I even argue with God about it. I whine and say, "It's not fair!" But ... I set my good old cruise control on 55 mph, and thank the Lord for the relationship I have with him. Getting to my destination faster, pales in comparison to growing my relationship deeper.
God's Word is not made up of optional suggestions. No. God's Word is made up of the laws that He wants us to live by.
Those that don't really know us, often put us into the "Legalistic Box" because of our lifestyle choices. However, we do NOT believe that any of the following choices are absolute Scriptural "rules". We see them as God's very BEST for OUR FAMILY ... but we would not tell anyone else that they are sinning if they don't make the same choice.
#1 We have 13 children. Most people
think that we don't believe in using any type of birth control. Not the case. We CHOSE to allow God to determine the size of our family. We do not look down AT ALL on families that only have 2 or 3 children. Most of our closest friends do NOT have large families.
#2 We homeschool our children. Again, most people
think that we believe every Christian family should teach their children at home. Not so. We believe that homeschooling is God's BEST for OUR FAMILY.
#3 We do not watch television (
except on rare occasions when staying at hotels). Many people
think that we believe that television is evil. Not so. We CHOSE to turn off our television 19 years ago, and have never regretted that decision. We believe it has been the BEST decision for OUR FAMILY. But, we do not judge those who do watch television. We might, however, encourage families about the type of television shows they are allowing into their homes. Shows that may not fit Godly standards.
#4 Our children do not attend Youth Group. We do not believe there is anything inherently wrong in church Youth Groups, however we do not believe that they have been the BEST option for our teenagers. On the flip side ... many of our older teens and young adults have worked as volunteer youth leaders, which we have absolutely encouraged.
#5 Our children sit in "big church" with us, starting at about age 5. Again, nothing inherently wrong with Children's Ministry (
our eldest daughter worked in full-time Children's Ministry for 2 years). However, it is actually our CHILDREN who have CHOSEN to worship with the family. They have asked if they can't PLEASE stay in "big church" with Papa and Mama. That has been God's BEST for OUR FAMILY ... even though we were BLESSED with the most absolutely amazing Children's Pastor at our church for 7 years.
#6 We do not watch R-rated movies. We do not believe that the majority of R-rated movies are honoring to the Lord. No, there is not a Scripture verse that says, "Don't watch R-rated movies.", but there are many that talk about "think on things that are pure ... holy ... and righteous". Most R-rated movies do not fit in that category.
#7 We do not "do" Santa Claus at our house. We have many friends that do. We have just CHOSEN to focus on the LORD as we celebrate His Birth. I might be concerned, though, if you are lying to your children about the authenticity of Santa Claus; because Scripture clearly tells us not to lie. Because of the Scriptural mandate not to lie ... we don't do the Easter Bunny or the Tooth Fairy either.
#8 We do not drink alcohol. (
Read my comments on Bianca's Post about that one.) This is a personal preference. This is what we believe is BEST for OUR FAMILY. We have many friends that see nothing wrong with having a beer or a glass of wine with dinner. I don't have a problem with that. However, if much of your social life is centered around drinking alcohol ... I've got a few questions for you.
We most certainly might
look like a very legalistic family. However, I believe the difference is that while we believe each of these "rules" are BEST for OUR FAMILY ... we do NOT try to put these rules onto anyone else.
On the flip side ...
About 12 years ago we joined an organization. It
looked good. It had a lot of "good programs" for the youth. We
thought that we would find a group of like-minded Believers. We couldn't have been further from the truth.
While, in our own local church, we were definitely known as the "very conservative" family ... when we joined this organization we suddenly became "the rebellious ones". Seriously. It was bad.
When we sent in our family picture with our application to join, we were at first rejected, because Papa had a beard. What??!! Yes, they saw all beards as a sign of rebelliousness from the 1970's. We were stuck. If we refused to shave the beard, they had just proved that we were rebellious. Jim shaved.
Then, we discovered all of the "rules".
#1 Birth control is an abomination of the Lord.
#2 Women must have as many children as they can possibly have.
#3 All women and girls must wear dresses at all times.
#4 All children must be educated at home.
#5 The King James Bible is the only valid Bible.
#6 All music except hymns are evil.
Oh my. We went from "very conservative" to "totally rebellious" in one day. While we did already have 8 children, we had used birth control. While I did like my denim jumpers, I also really liked my jeans. Our family much preferred the NIV Bible, and we loved our contemporary Christian music. We were in trouble. No, our affiliation with this organization did not last long.
However, we learned a LOT from our short time as members. We saw legalism up close and personal, and we wanted nothing to do with it. We did NOT see joy-filled families. We saw mothers that were over-burdened with their responsibilities to follow the rules. They were having babies because they were told to, not because they wanted to. As a group, they were the saddest bunch of mothers I had ever seen. It broke my heart.
So, while we may have tended a bit towards the legalistic side before our brief stint with that organization ... we quickly moved over to the grace-filled side. Our standards ... our rules ... for our family, did not change. But we saw how quickly things could go wrong when 1 person (
the head of the organization) decided that everyone MUST hold to the same convictions as he held to, or they were sinners.
If sitting down for a cup of tea with you, I would share all of the reasons that we have made the choices that we've made. I may encourage you to make a similar choice. I may challenge you to read Scriptures and seek wisdom in one of these areas (
if I see a specific problem). Yet, I would not call you a sinner if you made different choices for your family.
For those of you who tend to be far over on the "Freedom in Christ" side of things, I would encourage you to hold your tongue for a minute before crying "Legalism!!!". I would encourage you to really hear the person's heart. If they are making the choice for their own family, it is not necessarily legalism ... it's THEIR CHOICE. I would also encourage you to truly seek God's heart on matters that aren't specifically spelled out in scripture. Remember, even though everything might be "permissible" in our freedom in Christ, that does not mean that everything is beneficial. Wouldn't you rather have God's very BEST for your family, rather than just the "freedom" to do what
you want to do?
For those of you who tend to be far over on the "Legalistic" side of things, I would encourage you to really study the Scriptures. Don't just take someone's Word for what is Biblically right and wrong. Study God's Word so that you KNOW what is or is not a Biblical standard. Also, remember that there was a time when you did not hold the same scriptural convictions. You are still learning and maturing in your own relationship with Christ. So, I'd encourage you to give others the Grace that God gave you, before you learned what you now know.